“ What can I say! I have been going there for over 40. Great pizza as well as the large dishes and 3ft subs we order for large events. They NEVER DISAPPOINT!!! Enjoy ”

“ I've eaten here a few times, and it's already my favorite pizzeria in NJ. I recommend getting pizza by the slice and dining in. When they take the slice from the display and put it back in the oven, the crust gets this perfect crispy texture while the dough stays nice and chewy. The pizza/marinara sauce they use is so rich and flavorful. The white pizzas can be a hit or a miss. The Balsamic Chicken pizza was very good, but the Pesto Chicken was dry and not seasoned as well. The Garlic Knots were solid. I also tried their Chicken Parm Sandwich, and I was a fan. It had thick cuts of breaded chicken cutlets, their delicious marinara sauce, and gooey cheese between two very soft sub rolls. The bread was maybe a bit too soft, but I didn't mind it too much. The service was friendly, and the restaurant had a classic family-owned pizzeria vibe. I'll be coming back to eat here whenever I want pizza. ”

“ I am so lucky to be in walking distance to Brothers Pizzeria! I've been coming here for years, ever since I moved here from Brooklyn. Consistently good Brooklyn-style pizza, great sauce and toppings. The mini sausage and chicken rolls are also excellent. Try them out! ”

“ Excellent and consistent quality of food and service. All types of pizza are excellent. Also the seafood combo with linguine is excellent. ”

“ I love this spot. Anytime I'm home in Jersey I make it a point to stop by before I fly back home. The pizza here is perfectly thin, not too greasy and holds to the end when you fold it. The subs are ginormous and they always stuff it full. The workers are all super courteous and I always feel right at home here. Plenty of tables and a couple booths. I wish I didn't live across the country :( ”

“ We called in a takeout order for Stuffed Shells and a few slices of pizza (one vodka sauce, one plain), at around 7:05 and our food was ready to go by 7:15. The restaurant was very clean, the staff were friendly, and the food was pretty good! We thought the stuff shells were great (4/5), and the pizza was just okay (probably 2/5, although I think I might have been given a margarita slice instead of a vodka sauce slice). If you are in the area and you want something quick to eat, I would say this is a good stop! ”

“ Still the best pizza in the area and the reason we keep coming back. Great pizza and great food. ”

“ Was in the area, so had to try. Slices are delicious. Crust is a little thicker than I prefer but it's not dough-y. Sauce and cheese was delicious as well. Tried the vodka & cheese slice. Looking forward to trying more options on the menu ”

“ If you're a Staten Island transplant, you're going to love this pizza. They don't do delivery, but who wants to wait an hour for cold pizza. It's well worth picking it up yourself. They do pizza the right way! ”